
A while back, I was talking to a career Web site about writing articles for them. It sounded fun, and I was into it, but I couldn't get the contact woman to communicate very well. She didn't answer my questions and just kind of expected me to shoot out of the gates without any direction. And no mention of money, of course. So I gave up on that idea. But before filing away the opportunity in my brain, I had a thought about a little column I could write about master's degrees. And since I already have it right here saved on ye ole Macbook, I might as well share it, eh?
So if you know anyone who is confused about whether or not to go back to school, perhaps they will enjoy it.
Is a Master’s Degree Really that Important?by Blondie Blonderson
I always knew that I wanted to be an editor. I have box full of little books I made as a child in my loopy, crayoned handwriting. And so when the time came to go to college, I decided to major in English. I didn’t know any book editors, and I knew nothing about the industry. Four years later, I graduated and moved to Portland, Oregon. My first job was in acquisitions. I read endless manuscripts from the slush pile to find publishable material. I also worked in the publicity department making press kits and other marketing materials. I enjoyed the work, but the job wasn’t the right fit. After four months, I quit.
Portland is a lovely city. For the four years I was in college, I daydreamed about moving to Oregon. But there is something very different about the mentality in that part of the country. My friends in Portland were more interested in jobs than they were careers. They wanted to make money, sure, but they also wanted to go hiking and enjoy the beauty of the region. I knew very few hard-core business people. The people I knew in the Midwest were busy climbing corporate ladders and wearing fancy pantsuits. Portlanders? Not so much. So after a few months of searching for a new professional job, I decided to go work for Powell’s Books until I figured out what to do next.
While working at the bookstore, I read many books about careers. My friends from the University of Iowa were entering graduate school. Was this something I should be doing, too? I really didn’t want to. Something in my gut soured when I thought of going back to school. My English major really had nothing to do with being an editor. I spent most of my time reading classics and writing giant papers. Learning about the book publishing industry just didn’t happen. That was all self-taught. For free. To this day, I still feel that my degree has almost nothing to do with my career.
So when I thought about going to graduate school, I thought about spending a lot of money that I didn’t have for yet another certificate that would have nothing to do with my career. But I thought I would investigate it anyway. I read one of those books that has some fancy title about careers for English majors. The book pointed out something very interesting. Most people who get a master’s degree in English want to be a professor. And English professors? They teach FOREVER. Until they die. And then you? The person who just got that master’s degree? You have to move wherever there is an opening somewhere around the country. And then you have to fight it out with whoever else has been waiting in the wings with their fancy master’s degrees. Oof. This didn’t sound good. My gut turned away once again.
Ten years later, I have no regrets about not getting a master’s degree. My undergraduate degree was enough to get me into the world of publishing, and it looks nice on my resume. Other than that, there is no focus on it. I spent the last six years working in educational publishing. Many of my colleagues had epic debt from getting a master’s in education. And we were equals. Or sometimes, I had the higher title. In my particular industry, experience is what counts. I ran into more than one colleague who was 5+ years older than me but lower on the ladder because she spent so much time in school. And now she was in big trouble because her tiny salary couldn’t pay her school loans. I also had friends 10+ years older than me who were STILL trying to hack away at that debt even though they had outstanding titles. They all asked if I was going to pursue a graduate degree. My answer was a resounding no. Could I benefit from having one? Sure. But do I need it? No.
So how can you tell if you need a graduate degree? Here are some things to think about:
Your Industry In our high-tech world where people are jumping through the ranks with self-taught knowledge, where do you fit in? Does your industry require higher education? Research the career path you want, and find people at different levels. Shoot them an email to inquire about the degrees required to succeed in your field. Ask the assistants, the mid-level professionals, and someone in a senior position. How much schooling did they receive, and how did it help or hinder them?
Your Competition Think about the other people who are also on your career path. Did they get a graduate degree? Did it help them? Sometimes a master’s can actually hinder people. You might be able to get an entry-level job easier than your peers because your salary requirements would be lower. While your friends are racking up degrees, you can be out there getting the experience instead and building a healthy resume.
Money Getting a master’s degree can be extremely expensive. Or, if you’re lucky, you can get one for free. I know many professionals who had their master’s degrees paid for by their employers. Research your company’s education benefits to find out if you can get part of the degree (or the entire degree) paid for through them.
Time Realize, of course, that you will be working part- or full-time and going to school as well. Some people can handle this, and some people can’t. Be realistic about how much you can handle. If you’re thinking about working and going to school, create an experiment to show you how much time you’ll be spending on the degree. Block out the time in your schedule and go to the library to read a book or write hand-written letters for the hours you would be in the class. This will help you realize how much time you would be devoting to your education—but don’t forget the hours for homework!
Your Own Passion My sister always wanted a master’s degree in creative writing. She HAD to have it. Something inside of her wasn’t going to feel fulfilled until it was hers. So she went to school and did homework on weekends while working full-time. It was difficult, but she made it happen. It was extremely important to her, and she has no regrets. If you know you really want that degree, make it happen.
Even though I never did get that master’s, I still enjoy learning. I’ve kept up on my industry by reading professional newsletters, magazines, books, and attending trade shows. I truly believe in educating yourself for a lifetime, but I don’t believe you should have to struggle to do it. I believe my undergraduate degree was the best money ever spent. And, who knows, perhaps some day in the future I will find myself entering the halls of higher education once again. But for now, I’m feeling pretty good about my career. And I didn’t have to break the bank getting here.